Reform federal judge Care Health claims as a whole is unconstitutional

Reform federal judge Care Health claims as a whole is unconstitutional -

Yesterday, a federal judge in Florida was the first to declare that all health care reform is unconstitutional - marking one of the biggest court decisions on reform yet. Judge Roger Vinson is the second judge to determine that the reform is unconstitutional in a legal battle that will end up in the Supreme Court.

The decision to Vinson is distinguished because it has not struck down part of the reform, but the whole of the law. As the trial against the reform is one of the largest and represents 26 states across the nation reports The Washington Post .

Vinson does not believe the individual mandate health insurance is constitutional and that the term is closely related to almost every part of the reform. These connections through the law, it will be impossible to implement without warrant reform. He said, "The law, like a defectively designed watch, needs to be redesigned and reconstructed by the watchmaker"

The judge referred to the federal government when it came to the expansion of Medicaid. . States believes that the expansion of Medicaid imposes a heavy burden on them when they are already cash short and not have the budget. But the judge said that the federal government does not require states to participate in Medicaid and is their own decision.

of course, the Obama administration has taken to their blog in defense reform and minimize the decision calling it "a clear case of judicial too far."

again this decision is not the last and more courts will ultimately decide on the same issues.

Tweet